To label the latest offering from Elliott Smith a "departure" borders on oversimplification. Figure 8, Smith's fifth album, is a dreamy, layered work that merely ups the rock ante of his perfectly balanced 1998 release, XO -- an exquisite union of wistful acoustic stylings and polished pop. This singer's trademark has always been his uncanny ability to evoke tremendous emotion with minimal instumentation. Thus, initially, it was somewhat disconcerting to discover Smith's sweet pining vocals immersed among this luscious cacophony of bass and percussion.
What eventually becomes apparent on repeat listens is that Smith can rock with the best of them. "Junk Bond Trader" and "L.A." are rollicking showcases replete with some of the catchiest guitar work in recent memory. The former is a standout track that exposes artifice: "The imitation picks you up like a habit." With the omnipresent Jon Brion providing backing vocals, "Happiness" and "Wouldn't Mama Be Proud" are virtual prototypes of the earlier masterpieces on XO.
If you're looking for vintage Elliott Smith, his sweet alto voice and sparse arrangements are amply represented. "Easy Way Out" displays classic Smith lyrics -- "there's no escape for you except in someone else" -- delicately delivered with quiet devastation. The curiously sequenced "Everything Reminds Me of Her" and "Everything Means Nothing to Me" are, practically, paradoxical companion pieces -- stylistically and lyrically.
Though we may long to wallow along with Smith, we cannot deny his growth. He's chosen a livelier showcase here, though the usual suspects -- depression, disillusionment, and women troubles -- are never far beneath the surface. When asked during an interview what his idea of a perfect day was, Smith responded, "Making up a song that's surprising to me is pretty much where it's at. That's probably my favorite thing to do." In light of that remark, Elliott Smith has been having some very good days.
If you like Elliott Smith, check out:
Elliott Smith Elliott Smith
Elliott Smith Roman Candle
Elliott Smith Either/Or
Elliott Smith XO
Nick Drake Five Leaves Left
Aimee Mann Bachelor No. 2
Michael Penn MP4
Matthew Sweet In Reverse
The Beatles Magical Mystery Tour
Palace Viva Last Blues